Carlo Gesualdo: A Life of Music, Murder, and Magic

The badass composer turned mentally unstable criminal

Christopher Kokoski
5 min readMay 16, 2023
Cartoon image of Carlo Gesualdo — Carlo Gesualdo: A Life of Music, Murder, and Magic
Image created by the Author via DALL-E and Canva

The Renaissance was an era of flourishing arts and culture, of architectural grandeur, and yes, of some seriously twisted tales.

Among these, the saga of Carlo Gesualdo stands out as a story filled with passion, crime, and exceptionally groundbreaking music. This Italian nobleman, who also happened to be a prince, indeed wore the badass tag like a crown.

Let’s explore his dramatic and, dare we say, avant-garde life.

The Prince of Venosa: A Title to Kill For

First things first, let’s take a moment to appreciate how badass the title “Prince of Venosa” sounds.

It’s like something out of a dark fantasy novel, but it was reality for our man Gesualdo. Born in 1566, Carlo Gesualdo da Venosa was an Italian nobleman with a lineage that traced back to one of the oldest and most esteemed families in the Kingdom of Naples.

The prince himself was something of an enigma, a figure shrouded in mystery, intrigue, and, let’s not forget, scandal.

A Crime of Passion: The Infamous Double Murder

Gesualdo’s life took a chilling turn in 1590 when he found his wife, Maria d’Avalos, in the throes of passion with her lover, Duke Fabrizio Carafa.

Now, Gesualdo was no shrinking violet.

He took matters into his own hands in a way that would make even the most hardened crime bosses blanch. He murdered both his wife and her lover, a crime for which he was never punished due to his noble status.

But the prince didn’t just stop at murder.

In a gruesome display of rage, he reportedly placed the bodies of his victims on public display. It was a chilling and macabre spectacle that earned him a reputation as a man who not only broke the rules but who utterly shattered them.

Gesualdo the Composer: Breaking the Rules of Harmony

While Gesualdo’s scandalous personal life might steal the limelight, his work as a composer deserves equal, if not more, attention.

His music was as unconventional as his lifestyle, pushing the boundaries of 16th-century harmonic norms and venturing into a sonic landscape that can only be described as avant-garde.

His compositions, rich with chromaticism and unexpected harmonic shifts, were unlike anything heard during his time. The dissonant harmonies and complex polyphonic structures of his madrigals and sacred works were so ahead of their time that they still sound incredibly modern today, over four centuries later.

The Madrigals: Gesualdo’s Musical Rebellion

Perhaps the most fascinating aspect of Gesualdo’s musical portfolio is his madrigals. The madrigal, a form of secular vocal music, was a popular genre during the Renaissance, but Gesualdo took it to a whole new level.

His madrigals were marked by fierce independence and a tendency to flout the established rules of harmony.

The sudden shifts in tonality, the bizarre yet beautiful harmonies, the expressiveness of the text setting — all these elements combined to create a musical experience that was as shocking as it was enchanting.

Gesualdo’s Legacy: A Badass Until The End

Gesualdo’s life was filled with moments that could make even the most hardened cynics raise their eyebrows.

Yet, it is his daring approach to music and his fearlessness in the face of societal norms that truly cement his legacy as one of history’s most badass figures.

Even after his death, his music continues to mesmerize audiences with its uncanny modernity and its refusal to adhere to common best practices.

The Final Years: A Prince Shrouded in Mystery

In the later years of his life, Gesualdo’s actions became even more unpredictable and bizarre.

Following the scandalous murder and his subsequent remarriage, Gesualdo retreated to his castle in Venosa. Here, he isolated himself from society, engaging in acts of penance that were as extreme as the rest of his life.

The prince spent his final years in a haze of guilt and self-torture, seeking redemption for his deeds.

The Encylopedia of Brittanica says this of the man:

But his life remained turbulent; a contemporary account describes him as depressed whenever he was doing anything not related to music. He resorted to unusual measures to cure his physical and mental suffering, engaging in occult practices with his mistress and reportedly employing male servants whose job it was to beat him daily.

But even in this state of self-imposed isolation, Gesualdo continued to compose. His music from this period is intensely emotional, filled with an almost palpable sense of guilt and despair.

But true to his nature, even these expressions of penance were groundbreaking in their musical approach.

A Fascination for the Macabre: Gesualdo in Pop Culture

Gesualdo’s dramatic life story and his innovative music have intrigued artists and musicians for centuries, making him a fascinating figure in popular culture.

The prince-composer has been the subject of several operas, novels, and films that explore his life’s dual nature — the violent nobleman and the avant-garde composer.

From Werner Herzog’s Death for Five Voices to Salvatore Sciarrino’s opera Luci Mie Traditrici, Gesualdo’s life and music continue to inspire and captivate.

His unique combination of scandalous personal life and trailblazing musical contributions make him an irresistible figure in the collective cultural imagination.

The Final Chord: Gesualdo’s Enduring Legacy

So, was Carlo Gesualdo a badass?

Absolutely. A murderer and a madrigal composer, a prince, and a pariah, Gesualdo was a man who lived by his own rules.

His life was a symphony of scandal, violence, and groundbreaking music.

Even 400 years after his death, Gesualdo’s music feels surprisingly contemporary, with harmonic explorations that would not sound out of place in a 20th-century avant-garde concert.

His madrigals continue to be performed and recorded, captivating listeners with their daring harmonic twists and turns.

In the end, Carlo Gesualdo remains a striking example of how art can flourish even in the darkest corners of the human soul. His life, as tumultuous and scandalous as it was, has left a lasting legacy in the realm of music.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is the ultimate level of badassery.

Conclusion

The next time you’re at a party and someone asks you who your favorite historical badass is, you know who to pick.

Just remember to mention that the Prince of Venosa was not just a rule-breaking nobleman but also a trailblazing composer who pushed the boundaries of music and created works that resonate to this day.

Now, how badass is that?

--

--

Christopher Kokoski

Endlessly curious| proud word nerd| Don’t miss my next article — sign up to my Medium email list: https://bit.ly/3yy18Bc